Skip to Main Content
Story Hill BKC logo topStory Hill BKC logo scroll
  • (414)-539-4424
  • story@storyhillbkc.com
  • 5100 W Bluemound Rd , Milwaukee
  • MENU
  • DRINKS
  • SPECIALS
  • EVENTS
  • CATERING
  • PRIVATE DINING
  • CURBSIDE
  • RESERVATIONS
  • GIFT CARDS
  • CAREERS
  • BOTTLE SHOP / WINE CLUB
  • Twitter pageFacebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
Story Hill BKC logo topStory Hill BKC logo scroll
  • Twitter pageFacebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
  • MENU
  • DRINKS
  • SPECIALS
  • EVENTS
  • CATERING
  • PRIVATE DINING
  • CURBSIDE
  • RESERVATIONS
  • GIFT CARDS
  • CAREERS
  • BOTTLE SHOP / WINE CLUB

Our menu

LunchDinnerBrunchKids MenuMid-Day Menu

Lunch is served Tuesday-Friday 11 a.m. to 2 p.m.

Crepes

Crêpe Monsieur photo

Crêpe Monsieur

$16.00
Hickory smoked ham, Saxony alpine cheese, house-made pickles, dijonnaise, poached eggs, chives.
Crêp-urrito photo

Crêp-urrito

$16.00
Two local scrambled eggs, Saxony alpine cheese, jalapeño mayo, cumin-spiced tomato sauce, roasted marble potatoes (add meat $3).

Crêpe and Syrup

$8.00
Wisconsin maple syrup, powdered sugar (add meat $3).

Berries, Bananas, and Cream Crêpe

$15.00
Fresh berries, bananas, vanilla egg cream, spiced nut granola streusel.

Illuminated Specialties

Avocado Toast photo

Avocado Toast

$14.00
Rustic toast, smoked lentil puree, sliced avocado, cucumber, radish, olive oil, coarse sea salt.
Sirloin Steak Sandwich* photo

Sirloin Steak Sandwich*

$18.00
Carved medium-rare Angus beef, shallot butter, arugula, truffle peppercorn mayonnaise, seeded roll, one side.
Burger on the Hill* photo

Burger on the Hill*

$16.00
Half-pound Niman ranch burger, carr valley one year cheddar, jalapeño mayo, lettuce, tomato, red onion, pickle, our seeded bun, one side (add, fried egg $1, bacon $3).
Shakshouka* photo

Shakshouka*

$15.00
Two local eggs baked in cumin-spiced tomato sauce, smoked lentils, cilantro, goat cheese, sumac mayonnaise, flatbread.
The Emmel Grover photo

The Emmel Grover

$15.00
Curry roasted chicken salad, dried tart cherries, almonds, iceberg lettuce, tomato, thick-cut white or wheat, one side.
Pretzel Ham & Cheese photo

Pretzel Ham & Cheese

$16.00
Uphoff ham, beer cheddar, black garlic honey mustard, lettuce, tomato, BSB pretzel roll, one side.

BBQ Shiitake Wrap

$14.00
Soy bbq roasted shiitake mushrooms, miso mayo, black garlic mustard, radish & cabbage slaw, naan bread, one side.

Buff-Falafel Sandwich

$15.00
Fired Falafel Patty, Buffalo Sauce, Tahini Garlic Ranch, Olive Spread, Tomato, Onion, Cucumber seeded Bun

Storied Salads and Soups

Butternut Squash & Wild Rice Salad

$18.00
Mixed Greens, Wild Rice, Apple Cider Vinaigrette, Roasted Butternut Squash, Slab Bacon, Craisins, Crispy Brussel Sprouts, Honey Crisp Apples, Spiced Nuts, Crumbled Gorgonzola, Bourbon Cider Gastrique
Smoked Trout Salad photo

Smoked Trout Salad

$17.00
Cured & smoked steelhead trout, maple glazed pecans, radish, roasted fennel, baby kale, dill vinaigrette, crispy carrots.

Chicken Jalapeño Soup

$7.00
Bell & Evans chicken, masa dumplings, baby kale, avocado.

Sides

Roasted Caulifower Salad photo

Roasted Caulifower Salad

$6.00
Dried tomatoes, arugula, pesto, almonds, chile flakes, montamore, citrus vinaigrette.

The Brutus

$6.00
Lacinato kale, broccolini, montamore, lemon tahini dressing, butter flake croutons, everything bagel seasoning.
Roasted Beets photo

Roasted Beets

$6.00
Roasted Beets with Goat Cheese, Mint, and Pistachios

Fresh Fruit

$7.00
Banana, strawberry, blackberry, blueberry.

Roasted Marble Potatoes

$5.00
Shallot butter, coffee seasoning.

Pastry

Brandy Chocolate Chip Cookie

$4.00

Confetti Cake Cookie

$4.00

House-Made Cinnamon Roll

$5.00
Dark Chocolate Chiffon  Pie photo

Dark Chocolate Chiffon Pie

$10.00

Upside Down Cherry Cake

$10.00

Seasonal Coffee Cake

$4.00

Dinner is served Tuesday-Saturday 5-9 p.m.

Bindings

Sides to bind your meal into a complete story!

Braised Cabbage

$16.00
Miso Butter Basted Cabbage, Sauce Soubise, Pumpkin Seeds, Brassica Chimichurri, Fried Brussels sprout Leaves, Toasted Bread Crumbs
Roast Caulifower Salad photo

Roast Caulifower Salad

$11.00
Pesto, Dried Tomato, Montamoré, Toasted Almond, Chili Flakes.
Smoked Yukon  Au Gratin photo

Smoked Yukon Au Gratin

$14.00
Smoked Yukon potatoes, house ham, dill cream, carr valley one year cheddar, corn flake crust.

Taste

Just a taste of some things new, special, and carefully created

Fresh Baked Butter Flake Rolls photo

Fresh Baked Butter Flake Rolls

$8.00/three rolls
Salted butter (additional rolls $2.5).
Chicken Meatball photo

Chicken Meatball

$8.00
Truffle honey, green peppercorn sauce.
Crayfish Rangoons photo

Crayfish Rangoons

$14.00
Domestic crayfish & cream cheese, scallions, fried stuffed wontons, pepper jam gastrique

Escargot

$14.00
Spotted cow pan sauce, fresh-baked pretzel, Saxony cheese.

Twin Mushroom Hand Pies

$16.00
Local mushroom duxelles, shredded Saxony and montamoré, sherry syrup, thyme almond gremolata
Milwaukee Beef Tartare photo

Milwaukee Beef Tartare

$18.00
Fresh Ground Certified Angus Beef, Roasted Garlic Aioli, Capers, Shallots, Trout Roe, Crostini, Maldon Sea Salt

Share

Dishes to enjoy in the popular sharing plate style

Grande Mozzarella photo

Grande Mozzarella

$16.00
Fresh Grande Mozzarella, Calabrian Chili & Tomato Agrodolce, Pinenuts, Roasted Fennel, Crispy Soppressata, Basil, Fennel Pesto Buttered Toast

Wisconsin Cheese Plate

$19.00
Roelli Red Rock Cheddar, Marieke Fenugreek Gouda, Door County Artisan Butterkase, Satsuma Cranberry Mostarda, Onion Marmalade, Sliced Uphoff Ham, Honey Crisp Apple, Crostini

Butternut Squash & Wild Rice Salad

$17.00
100 Acre Greens, Apple Cider Vinaigrette, Wild Rice, Roasted Butternut Squash, Gorgonzola, Slab Bacon, Craisins, Honey Crispy Apples, Spiced Nuts, Bourbon Cider Gastrique
Pub Cheese Burger photo

Pub Cheese Burger

$18.00
English Hollow Pub Cheese, Steak House Seasoned 8oz Niman Ranch Beef Patty, Tart Cherry Steak Sauce, Arugula, Truffle Peppercorn Mayo, House Pickles, Bacon Jam, Shoe String Potatoes, BSB Seeded Bun

Pass

Slightly oversized main plates that you can Pass around the table.

Cedar Plank Steelhead Trout photo

Cedar Plank Steelhead Trout

$34.00
Smoked maple mustard glaze, everything potato waffle, dill creme fraiche, trout roe

Roasted Mushroom Cacio e Pepe

$26.00
Roasted Oyster & Shiitake Mushrooms, Bucatini, Confit Tomatoes, Montamore and Black Pepper Pan Sauce, Toasted Almonds, Parsley

Butter Chicken Thighs

$30.00
Kashmiri Spiced Bell and Evas Chicken Thighs, Creamy Butter Chicken Sauce, Garlic and Saffron Rice Jasmine Rice, Naan Bread, Cilantro
Pork Chop Schnitzel photo

Pork Chop Schnitzel

$35.00
14 oz. Bone-in & Panko crusted pork chop, bacon roasted German potato salad (add an egg $2).
Beef Short Rib Gnocchi photo

Beef Short Rib Gnocchi

$34.00
Tomato braised beef short rib, house-made potato gnocchi, balsamic braised red cabbage, spinach, mustard, braising reduction.

Story Hill Steak

$39.00
12oz certified Angus beef sirloin, coffee butter, quarry-style

Brunch is served Saturday & Sunday 9 a.m. to 2 p.m.

Crepes

Crêpe and Syrup

$8.00
Wisconsin maple syrup, powdered sugar (add meat $3).
Crêpe Monsieur photo

Crêpe Monsieur

$14.00
Hickory smoked ham, Saxony alpine cheese, house-made pickles, dijonnaise, poached eggs, chives.

Berries, Bananas, and Cream Crêpe

$14.00
Fresh berries, bananas, vanilla egg cream, spiced nut granola streusel.
Crêp-urrito photo

Crêp-urrito

$14.00
Two local scrambled eggs, Saxony alpine cheese, jalapeño mayo, cumin-spiced tomato sauce, roasted marble potatoes (add meat $3).

Short Story

Eggs, Meat, and Toast

$13.00
Two local eggs, choice of meat, roasted marble potatoes, rustic toast.
Frittata photo

Frittata

$15.00
Local eggs, cherry wood bacon, house-dried tomatoes, aged carr valley cheddar, shredded potatoes, baby kale salad.

Broccoli Cheddar Egg Bake

$15.00
Egg Custard Soaked Bread, Fresh Broccolini, Cherrywood Bacon, Cheddar Cheese, Poached Eggs, Hollandaise, Baby Kale Salad, Roasted Marble Potatoes
Brunch Burger photo

Brunch Burger

$15.00
8 oz Niman Ranch Burger Patty, BSB Seeded Bun, Egg, Jalapeño Mayo, One Year Cheddar, Tomato, Onion, Lettuce, Roasted Marble Potatoes.

Illuminated Specialties

Shakshouka photo

Shakshouka

$14.00
Two local eggs baked in cumin-spiced tomato sauce, smoked lentils, cilantro, goat cheese, sumac mayonnaise, flatbread.

Greek Yogurt Panna Cotta

$14.00
Fresh berries, banana, local honey, spiced roasted nuts, dark chocolate.

Pastries

Sausage Roll

$4.00
Zesty sausage link, grain mustard, puff pastry.

Brandy Chocolate Chip Cookie

$4.00

Molasses Cookie

$4.00

House-Made Cinnamon Roll

$5.00

Seasonal Coffee Cake

$4.00

Toasts

Quark and Bread

$8.00
Rustic toast, Clock Shadow quark, house-made berry jam, local honey, spice roasted nuts.
Avocado Toast photo

Avocado Toast

$14.00
Rustic toast, smoked lentil puree, sliced avocado, cucumber, radish, olive oil, coarse sea salt.

Baked Tomato Bread

$9.00
Oven-toasted rustic bread, truffle creme fraiche, fresh sliced tomato, montamore cheese, fresh basil (add meat $3).

Sides

House Smoked Ham

$5.00

House-Made Sausage Patty

$5.00

Cherry Wood Bacon

$5.00

Fresh Fruit and Berries

$6.00

Rustic Toast (Two Slices)

$3.00

Two Local Eggs

$4.00

Roasted Marble Potatoes

$4.00

Kids menu for children 12 and under, please. Enjoying raw or undercooked meat, seafood, or eggs may affect your health.

Brunch

Served until 1 PM.

Plain Crepe

$4.00
With syrup (add Nuttela $1).

Berry Crepe

$6.00
With vanilla sauce.

Toast

$2.00
With housemade mixed berry jelly.

One Egg, Bacon, and Toast

$5.00
With housemade mixed berry jelly.

All Day

Kids Flatbread

$6.00
Marinara, montamore (add chicken $2, sausage $2 ).

Kids Macaroni

$4.00
Choice of buttered noodles, marinara, cheese sauce, fresh fruit, chefs veg, or side salad (add chicken $2, chicken meatball $3).

Chicken Fingers

$6.00
Panko breaded chicken breast, bbq sauce, choice of fresh fruit, chefs veg, or side salad.

Sides

Large Fruit

$6.00
Fresh berries and banana.

Chefs Vegetable

$4.00
Seasonal sauteed vegetable.

Kids Salad

$5.00
Mixed greens, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, vinaigrette.

The Mid-Day Menu is served Tuesday-Saturday 3 p.m. to 4:45 p.m.

Mid-Day Menu

Chicken Jalapeño Soup

$7.00
Bell & Evans chicken, Masa dumplings, baby kale, avocado.
Chicken Meatballs photo

Chicken Meatballs

$12.00
Two house-made chicken meatballs, truffle honey, green peppercorn sauce, buttered pretzel knot.

Wisconsin Cheese Plate

$19.00
Roelli Red Rock cheddar, Marieke Fenugreek gouda, Door County Artisan butterkase, Satsuma cranberry mostarda, onion marmalade, sliced Uphoff ham, honey crisp apple, crostini.

Confit Garlic Toast

$12.00
Confit Garlic & Tomatoes, Fennel Buttered Rustic Toast, Oregano, Basil, Sea Salt
  • Order
  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs