Skip to Main Content
Story Hill BKC logo topStory Hill BKC logo scroll
  • (414)-539-4424
  • story@storyhillbkc.com
  • 5100 W Bluemound Rd , Milwaukee
  • MENU
  • DRINKS
  • RESERVATIONS
  • ORDER CARRYOUT
  • CATERING
  • PRIVATE PARTIES
  • GIFT CARDS
  • CAREERS
  • BOTTLE SHOP / WINE CLUB
  • Facebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
Story Hill BKC logo topStory Hill BKC logo scroll
  • Facebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
  • MENU
  • DRINKS
  • RESERVATIONS
  • ORDER CARRYOUT
  • CATERING
  • PRIVATE PARTIES
  • GIFT CARDS
  • CAREERS
  • BOTTLE SHOP / WINE CLUB

Our menu

LunchDinnerBrunchMid-Day Menu

Lunch is served Tuesday-Friday 11 a.m. to 2 p.m.

Crepes

Crêpe Monsieur photo

Crêpe Monsieur

$17.50
Hickory smoked ham, Saxony Alpine Cheese, house-made pickles, dijonnaise, poached eggs, chives.
Crêp-urrito photo

Crêp-urrito

$18.00
Two local scrambled eggs, Saxony Alpine Cheese, Jalapeño mayo, cumin-spiced tomato sauce, roasted marble potatoes (add meat $4).

Crêpe and Syrup

$9.50
Wisconsin maple syrup, powdered sugar (add meat $4).

Berries, Bananas, and Cream Crêpe

$16.50
Fresh berries, bananas, vanilla egg cream, spiced nut granola streusel.

Illuminated Specialties

Avocado Toast photo

Avocado Toast

$16.00
Rustic toast, smoked lentil puree, sliced avocado, cucumber, radish, olive oil, coarse sea salt.
Sirloin Steak Sandwich* photo

Sirloin Steak Sandwich*

$20.00
Carved medium-rare Angus beef, shallot butter, arugula, truffle peppercorn mayonnaise, seeded roll, one side.
Burger on the Hill* photo

Burger on the Hill*

$16.50
Half Pound Midwest Hereford Patty, Two Year Sharp Cheddar, Jalapeño Mayo, Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion, Pickle, our Seeded Bun, one side (add, fried egg $2, bacon $4).
Shakshouka* photo

Shakshouka*

$17.00
Two local eggs baked in cumin-spiced tomato sauce, smoked lentils, cilantro, goat cheese, sumac mayonnaise, naan

Italian Ham Bomber

$18.00
Warm Uphoff Ham, Montamore, Toasted French Roll, Pork Spread, Roasted Garlic Mayo, House Giardiniera, Arugula, Choice of One Side

Mushroom Gyro

$16.00
Greek Spiced Roasted Mushrooms, Naan Bread, Tzatziki, Tomato, Cucumber, Red Onion, Feta Cheese, Fresh Mint, Roasted Garlic Olive Oil, Choice of One Side

Kimchi Chicken Salad Wrap

$17.00
House Kimchi Chicken Salad Wrap, Red Cabbage, Cucumber, Cilantro, Roasted Cashews, Katsu Sauce, Naan Bread, Choice of One Side

Burrata or The Egg

$18.00
Rustic Toast, Pesto Creme Fraiche, Bruschetta, Burrata, Poached Egg, 100 Acres Greens, Montamore Cheese, Pickled Onion, Balsamic Glaze

Storied Salads and Soups

Butternut Squash & Wild Rice Salad

$18.50
Mixed Greens, Wild Rice, Apple Cider Vinaigrette, Roasted Butternut Squash, Slab Bacon, Craisins, Crispy Brussel Sprouts, Honey Crisp Apples, Spiced Nuts, Crumbled Gorgonzola, Bourbon Cider Gastrique
Smoked Trout Salad photo

Smoked Trout Salad

$19.00
Cured & smoked steelhead trout, maple glazed pecans, radish, roasted fennel, baby kale, dill vinaigrette, crispy carrots.

Cast Iron Steak Salad

$21.00
Seared & Sliced Prime Hanger Steak, Mixed Greens, Montamore, Herb Roasted Potatoes, Oven Dried Tomatoes, Cured Olives, Basil Pesto, Citrus Vinaigrette, Croutons, Balsamic Glaze, Pickled Onion

Chicken Jalapeño Soup

$7.50
Bell & Evans chicken, masa dumplings, baby kale, avocado.

Sides

Roasted Caulifower Salad photo

Roasted Caulifower Salad

$8.00
Dried tomatoes, arugula, pesto, almonds, chile flakes, montamore, citrus vinaigrette.

The Brutus

$6.00
Lacinato kale, broccolini, montamore, lemon tahini dressing, butter flake croutons, everything bagel seasoning.

Roasted Beets

$6.00
Quark, Mint, Pistachio

Fresh Fruit

$8.00
Banana, strawberry, blackberry, blueberry.

Roasted Marble Potatoes

$7.00
Shallot butter, coffee seasoning.

Pastry

Brandy Chocolate Chip Cookie

$4.00

Seasonal Cookie

$4.00

House-Made Cinnamon Roll

$5.00

Dark Chocolate Chiffon Pie

$10.00

Upside Down Cherry Cake

$10.00

Seasonal Coffee Cake

$4.50

Dinner is served Tuesday-Saturday 5-9 p.m.

Bindings

Sides to bind your meal into a complete story!

Roast Caulifower Salad photo

Roast Caulifower Salad

$14.00
Pesto, Dried Tomato, Montamoré, Arugula, Toasted Almond, Chili Flakes.
Smoked Yukon  Au Gratin photo

Smoked Yukon Au Gratin

$15.00
Smoked Yukon potatoes, house ham, dill cream, carr valley one year cheddar, corn flake crust.
Seared Brussels Sprouts photo

Seared Brussels Sprouts

$16.00
Caramelized Brussels Sprouts, Smoked Bacon, Dried Cranberries, Toasted Pecans, Hooks Gorgonzola Cheese, Garlic Aioli
Barbecue Roasted Carrots photo

Barbecue Roasted Carrots

$16.00
Eggplant Hummus, Thyme Labneh, Pickled Golden Raisins, Almonds, Smoked Sea Salt, Chives

Taste

Just a taste of some things new, special, and carefully created

Fresh Baked Butter Flake Rolls photo

Fresh Baked Butter Flake Rolls

$8.00/three rolls
Salted butter (additional rolls $3).
Chicken Meatball photo

Chicken Meatball

$8.00
Truffle honey, green peppercorn sauce.
Crayfish Rangoons photo

Crayfish Rangoons

$16.00
Domestic crayfish & cream cheese, scallions, fried stuffed wontons, pepper jam gastrique
Escargot photo

Escargot

$18.00
Spotted cow pan sauce, fresh-baked pretzel roll, Saxony cheese.

Twin Mushroom Hand Pies

$17.00
Local mushroom duxelles, shredded Saxony and montamoré, sherry syrup, thyme almond gremolata
Za'atar Veal Ribs photo

Za'atar Veal Ribs

$16.00
Garlic & Thyme Braising Reduction, Lemon Tahini Yogurt, Toasted Pistachio
Rosemary Brie Pull Apart Bread photo

Rosemary Brie Pull Apart Bread

$16.00
Honey & Rosemary Triple Cream Brie, Rustic Toast Bread, Pistachio Gremolata, Cider Gastrique, MKE Microgreens

Share

Dishes to enjoy in the popular sharing plate style

Milwakee Beef Tartare photo

Milwakee Beef Tartare

$19.00
Fresh Ground Certified Angus Beef, Roasted Garlic Aioli, Capers, Shallots, Trout Roe, Crostini, Maldon Sea Salt
Wisconsin Cheese Plate photo

Wisconsin Cheese Plate

$22.00
Hooks EWE Calf To Be Kidding Blue Cheese, Carr Valley Cave Aged Marisa Cheese, Roth Prairie Sunset, Date Compote, Sherry Poached Pears, Honey Crisp Apples, Crostini

Butternut Squash & Wild Rice Salad

$19.00
100 Acre Greens, Apple Cider Vinaigrette, Wild Rice, Roasted Butternut Squash, Gorgonzola, Slab Bacon, Craisins, Honey Crispy Apples, Spiced Nuts, Bourbon Cider Gastrique
Whipped Feta photo

Whipped Feta

$18.00
Garlic Whipped Feta, Slab Bacon, Pomegranate Molasses, Aleppo Pepper, Smoked Honey, Almonds, Pine Nuts, Fresh Herbs, Naan
Roasted Delicata Squash photo

Roasted Delicata Squash

$18.00
Mixed Grain Pilaf, Laclare Goat Cheese, Toasted Pepitas, Miso Chili Maple, Scallions - Add Sunny Egg +$2

Pass

Slightly oversized main plates that you can Pass around the table.

Cedar Plank Steelhead Trout photo

Cedar Plank Steelhead Trout

$35.00
Smoked maple mustard glaze, everything potato waffle, dill creme fraiche, trout roe
Butter Chicken Thighs photo

Butter Chicken Thighs

$34.00
Kashmiri Spiced Bell And Evans Thighs, Creamy Cashew Butter Chicken Sauce, Garlic and Saffron Jasmine RIce, Naan Bread, Cilantro

Puttanesca Pork Tenderloin

$34.00
10oz Duroc Pork Tenderloin, Herb Crust, Creamy Polenta, Puttanesca Pan Sauce, Pesto Crunch, Balsamic Glaze, MKE Microgreens
Beef Short Rib Gnocchi photo

Beef Short Rib Gnocchi

$36.00
Red Wine braised beef short rib, house-made potato gnocchi, balsamic braised red cabbage, spinach, mustard, braising reduction.
Story Hill Steak photo

Story Hill Steak

$40.00
12oz certified Angus beef sirloin, coffee butter, quarry-style (Make it MKE Style! Cheese Curds, Demi, Shallots, Gherkin +$8)
Roasted Sweet Potato Agnolotti photo

Roasted Sweet Potato Agnolotti

$32.00
Black Garlic Pasta, Roasted Sweet Potato & Ricotta Filling, Sauce Soubise, Maple Pecans, Tart Cherry Coulis, Fried Sage

Brunch is served Saturday & Sunday 9 a.m. to 2 p.m.

Crepes

Crêpe and Syrup

$9.50
Wisconsin maple syrup, powdered sugar (add meat $4).
Crêpe Monsieur photo

Crêpe Monsieur

$17.50
Hickory smoked ham, Saxony alpine cheese, house-made pickles, dijonnaise, poached eggs, chives.

Berries, Bananas, and Cream Crêpe

$16.50
Fresh berries, bananas, vanilla egg cream, spiced nut granola streusel.
Crêp-urrito photo

Crêp-urrito

$17.50
Two local scrambled eggs, Saxony alpine cheese, jalapeño mayo, cumin-spiced tomato sauce, roasted marble potatoes (add meat $4).

Short Story

Eggs, Meat, and Toast

$14.00
Two local eggs, choice of meat, roasted marble potatoes, rustic toast.
Chef Fuel Frittata photo

Chef Fuel Frittata

$18.00
3 Local Eggs Baked with Rustic Toast, Bacon & Aged Cheddar, Spud Puppies, Blue Mound 51 Ketchup, 100 Acre Greens Salad, Chives

Mushroom & Spinach Waffle

$17.00
Wild Mushroom & Spinach Bread Pudding Waffle, Mushroom Duxelle, Roasted Broccolini, 100 Acre Greens, Feta Cheese, Truffle Oil, Poached Eggs, Smoked Shallot Marmalade
Brunch Burger photo

Brunch Burger

$17.00
1/2# Midwest Hereford Burger Patty, Toasted Bun, Sunny Egg, Jalapeño Mayo, One Year Cheddar, Tomato, Onion, Lettuce, Roasted Potatoes. (Add Bacon $4)

Illuminated Specialties

Shakshouka photo

Shakshouka

$17.00
Two local eggs baked in cumin-spiced tomato sauce, smoked lentils, cilantro, goat cheese, sumac mayonnaise, flatbread.

Greek Yogurt Panna Cotta

$14.00
Fresh berries, banana, local honey, spiced roasted nuts, dark chocolate.

Pastries

Sausage Roll

$5.00
Zesty sausage link, grain mustard, puff pastry.

Brandy Chocolate Chip Cookie

$4.00

Seasonal Cookie

$4.00

House-Made Cinnamon Roll

$5.00

Seasonal Coffee Cake

$4.50

Toasts

Quark and Bread

$8.00
Rustic toast, Clock Shadow quark, house-made berry jam, local honey, spice roasted nuts.
Avocado Toast photo

Avocado Toast

$16.00
Rustic toast, smoked lentil puree, sliced avocado, cucumber, radish, olive oil, coarse sea salt.

Baked Tomato Bread

$9.00
Oven-toasted rustic bread, truffle creme fraiche, fresh sliced tomato, montamore cheese, fresh basil (add meat $4).

Sides

House Smoked Ham

$6.00

House-Made Sausage Patty

$6.00

Cherry Wood Bacon

$6.00

Fresh Fruit and Berries

$7.00

Rustic Toast (Two Slices)

$3.00

Two Local Eggs

$4.00

Roasted Marble Potatoes

$7.00

The Mid-Day Menu is served Tuesday-Saturday 3 p.m. to 4:45 p.m.

Mid-Day Menu

Chicken Jalapeño Soup

$7.50
Bell & Evans chicken, Masa dumplings, baby kale, avocado.
Roasted Cauliflower Salad photo

Roasted Cauliflower Salad

$14.00
Pesto, dried tomato, arugula, montamore, toasted almonds, chili flakes.
Chicken Meatballs photo

Chicken Meatballs

$12.00
Two house-made chicken meatballs, truffle honey, green peppercorn sauce, buttered pretzel knot.

Whipped Feta

$18.00
Garlic Whipped Feta, Slab Bacon, Aleppo Pepper, Pomegranate Molasses, Smoked Honey, Almonds, Pine Nuts, Fresh Herbs, Naan Bread

Mushroom Flatbread

$15.00
Black Shoe Bakery flatbread, mushroom duxelles, roasted mushrooms, montamore, arugula, sherry syrup.

Butternut Squash & Wild Rice Salad

$19.00
Hundred Acre greens, apple cider vinaigrette, wild rice, roasted butternut squash, slab bacon, gorgonzola, craisins, spiced nuts, honeycrisp apple, bourbon cider gastrique.

Wisconsin Cheese Plate

$22.00
Hook's Ewe Calf To Be Kidding, Carr Valley Cave Aged Marisa, Roth Prairie Sunset, Date Compote, Sherry Poached Pears, Honey Crisp Apple, Crostini

For the Sweet Tooth

Seasonal Coffee Cake

$4.50

Seasonal Cookie

$4.00

Brandy Chocolate Chip Cookie

$4.00

Daily Pie

$8.00
  • Order
  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs