It's time for cocktails.

We love a good cocktail. Tap it, batch it, shake it, stir it – just don’t keep me waiting. We’ll pour you a taste of any of our artisan spirits, or mix it into a drink to match your fancy. A great dining experience, or a casual night out, is bound to include a couple cocktails.

Community Cocktail

Each month, we toast a local community organization with a cocktail! $1 from every featured cocktail enjoyed in May and June will go to our community partner: HOPE Network, a grassroots self-help support system for single mothers and single pregnant women living in Milwaukee, Waukesha, Washington, Ozaukee and Racine counties. Founded in 1982, HOPE Network offers programs designed to help mothers gain a sense of community, enhance their parenting skills and develop self-reliance. Our Community Cocktail is Sangria on tap.

$2 OFF Tap Cocktails during Happy Hour

Tue-Sat, 2 PM-6 PM

Cocktails on Tap

Apple Spice Sour – 7

Brandy, Lemon, Chai Spices, Apple (try it mulled for $1 more!)

Red Sangria – 6

Red Wine, Dark Rum, Orange, Lemon, Elderflower Syrup

The B.K.C. – 13

Rye, Cognac, Sweet Vermouth, Bitters, Jasmine, Chamomile

The Business – 7

Gin, Limoncello, Agave Nectar, Lime

Jalapeño Paloma – 8

Jalapeño Tequila, Grapefruit, Blood Orange, Rosemary

The Oldest Fashioned – 9

Bourbon, Orange, Sugar, Cherry, Bitters

Demerac – 9

5-yr Aged Demerara Rum, English Breakfast Tea, Bitters, Absinthe

Bourbon Sweet Tea – 7

Bourbon, Tamarind, Herbal and Black Teas

All Tap Cocktails are $2 Off During Happy Hour, 2-6 PM, Tues-Sat

After Dinner

Spiked Mexican Mocha – 8

Espolón Reposado, Espresso, Chocolate, Spices, Steamed Milk

An Irishman in the Cold

Irishman Irish Cream and Whiskey, Honey, Espresso, Cinnamon, Milk, Whipped Cream

Port – 4

Stones Throw of Door County, 2009, Napa Valley, CA

Port – 6

Fonseca, 10yr Tawny, nv, Portugal

Port – 5

Dow's Late Bottle Vintage, Portugal

Vintage Port – 10

Kopke, 2006, Douro, Portugal

Vintage Port – 14

Churchill's, 2011, Oporto, Portugal

Coffee Drinks

Iced Frothed Mocha – 5

Valentine Espresso, Chocolate Syrup, Hand-Frothed Milk

Mexican Mocha – 4.5

Valentine Espresso, Chocolate Syrup, House-blended Spices,  Steamed Milk

Story Hill Cocoa Toddy – 4.5

Valentine Cold Brewed Coffee, Monin Chocolate Syrup, Half & Half

Italian Soda – 3

Raspberry, Cherry, Peach, Vanilla, Caramel, Hazelnut, Mint, or Chocolate

Iced Vanilla Creme – 4

Espresso, House-made Vanilla Egg Cream, Milk, Whipped Cream

Lavender Iced Tea – 3

Iced Tea, Housemade Lavender Syrup (75-cent refills)

Cold-Brewed Coffee – 4

Latte/Cappuccino – 3.5


Sun 9am-2pm


Tue-Fri 11am-9pm

Sat 9am-9pm

Shop always closed by 9pm

Bar & Shop Only 2-3pm Menus


5100 W. Bluemound Rd. Milwaukee, Wisc.

PH 414.539.4424



DRINKS 2pm-6pm; MENU 3pm-5pm

$2 off tap cocktails

$2 off tap beer

$5 featured wine by the glass

To apply at Story Hill, download and complete this application.