It's time for cocktails.

We love a good cocktail. Tap it, batch it, shake it, stir it – just don’t keep me waiting. We’ll pour you a taste of any of our artisan spirits, or mix it into a drink to match your fancy. A great dining experience, or a casual night out, is bound to include a couple cocktails.

Community Cocktail

Each month, we toast a local community organization with a cocktail! $1 from every featured cocktail enjoyed in September and October will go to our community partner: Pathfinders. Pathfinders is a comprehensive and effective service provider for runaway, throwaway, and homeless young people. By employing a housing-first model, Pathfinders ensures that youth are given a safe and stable environment – and then provided with the additional services that will help them find success. Click image to learn more about Pathfinders.

$2 OFF Tap Cocktails during Happy Hour

Tue-Sat, 2 PM-6 PM

Cocktails on Tap

Apple Spice Sour – 7

Brandy, Lemon, Chai Spices, Apple (try it mulled for $1 more!)

Red Sangria – 6

Red Wine, Dark Rum, Orange, Lemon, Elderflower Syrup

The B.K.C. – 13

Rye, Cognac, Sweet Vermouth, Bitters, Jasmine, Chamomile

The Business – 7

Gin, Limoncello, Agave Nectar, Lime

Jalapeño Paloma – 8

Jalapeño Tequila, Grapefruit, Blood Orange, Rosemary

The Oldest Fashioned – 9

Bourbon, Orange, Sugar, Cherry, Bitters

Demerac – 9

5-yr Aged Demerara Rum, English Breakfast Tea, Bitters, Absinthe

Bourbon Sweet Tea – 7

Bourbon, Tamarind, Herbal and Black Teas

All Tap Cocktails are $2 Off During Happy Hour, 2-6 PM, Tues-Sat

After Dinner

Spiked Mexican Mocha – 8

Espolón Reposado, Espresso, Chocolate, Spices, Steamed Milk

An Irishman in the Cold

Irishman Irish Cream and Whiskey, Honey, Espresso, Cinnamon, Milk, Whipped Cream

Port – 4

Stones Throw of Door County, 2009, Napa Valley, CA

Port – 6

Fonseca, 10yr Tawny, nv, Portugal

Port – 5

Dow's Late Bottle Vintage, Portugal

Vintage Port – 10

Kopke, 2006, Douro, Portugal

Vintage Port – 14

Churchill's, 2011, Oporto, Portugal

Coffee Drinks

Iced Frothed Mocha – 5

Valentine Espresso, Chocolate Syrup, Hand-Frothed Milk

Mexican Mocha – 4.5

Valentine Espresso, Chocolate Syrup, House-blended Spices,  Steamed Milk

Story Hill Cocoa Toddy – 4.5

Valentine Cold Brewed Coffee, Monin Chocolate Syrup, Half & Half

Italian Soda – 3

Raspberry, Cherry, Peach, Vanilla, Caramel, Hazelnut, Mint, or Chocolate

Iced Vanilla Creme – 4

Espresso, House-made Vanilla Egg Cream, Milk, Whipped Cream

Lavender Iced Tea – 3

Iced Tea, Housemade Lavender Syrup (75-cent refills)

Cold-Brewed Coffee – 4

Latte/Cappuccino – 3.5


Sun 9am-2pm


Tue-Fri 11am-9pm

Sat 9am-9pm

Shop always closed by 9pm


5100 W. Bluemound Rd. Milwaukee, Wisc.

PH 414.539.4424



DRINKS 2pm-6pm; MENU 3pm-5pm

$2 off tap cocktails

$2 off tap beer

$5 featured wine by the glass

To apply at Story Hill, download and complete this application.