Your New Wine Shop

We want to help you find your new favorite. We carefully choose exceptional products and we want to know what you think. We're educated enthusiasts, not experts and definitely not snobs. We’ll get you loaded up on coffee and beer, too.

Wine Spectator 2015

Award of Excellence

Click for complete WINE LIST.
Prices are dine-in.


in the shop...

Next to a carefully chosen selection of interesting wine, craft spirits and beer, you'll find a selection of cocktail ingredients including Luxardo cherries and Bittercube bitters. Grab a greeting card from Artery Ink to go with your gift, and don't forget something for the pup! Story Hill carries the locally-made, all-natural dog treats Yumlies!. Click to learn more.

Sign up to be a Best Guest, or check your club card balance here.

What we're drinking


Cab/Shiraz/Monastrell Red Blend; Juan Gil 100th Anniversary

Jumilla, Spain 2013

Elegant and structured with black plum, currant, mocha, leather and tobacco.

Brunello di Montalcino; Piccini, Villa Al Cortile

Tuscany, Italy 2010

The vintage of the century from one of the world's great regions... for just 12 bucks a glass.

Shiraz; Peter Lehmann , Portrait

Barossa Valley, AUS 2014

Deep purple color with top notes of dark fruits and hints of chocolate and vanilla. We recommend with The Carve and the Wisconsin Cheese Plate.


Chardonnay: Beringer, Private Reserve

Napa Valley, CA 2014

When someone says the oaky-ness is "integrated" – this is what they mean. Ripe, juicy, with layers of flavor wrapping around the toasty oak.

Sparkling: Argyle Brut

Willamette Valley, OR

Skilled at growing Pinot Noir and Chardonnay – 2/3 of Champagne grapes – Argyle stamps a vintage on its sparkling to show the particular excellence of 2010. Bright citrus is balanced by a striking structure, breadlike body and a creamy finish.

Albariño: Tangent, Paragon Vineyard

Edna Valley, CA 2014

Spain's most famous white varietal finds a home in California. Orange and tangerine throughout, with balanced and crisp acidity. Refreshing as a cocktail wine, or with fresh fish.



Central Waters

Amherst, WI

Bourbon Barrel Stout 2015, Barrel-Aged Imperial Stout, 10%, 7/small tulip

Central Waters

Amherst, WI

Cassian Sunset, Barrel-Aged Stout with Vanilla, Cinnamon and Coffee, 10%, 8/small tulip


Kalamazoo, MI

Smitten Golden Rye, Rye Ale, 6%, 6/pint

Great Lakes

Cleveland, OH

Conway's Irish Ale, Irish Red Ale, 6.5%, 6/pint

Join the

Wine Club

We want to help you drink better, here and at home. Sign up to hear about the latest hot deals and get additional discounts. Want Email Updates on Hot Deals?


Sun 9am-2pm


Tue-Fri 11am-9pm

Sat 9am-9pm

Shop always closed by 9pm


5100 W. Bluemound Rd. Milwaukee, Wisc.

PH 414.539.4424



DRINKS 2pm-6pm; MENU 3pm-5pm

$2 off tap cocktails

$2 off tap beer

$5 featured wine by the glass

To apply at Story Hill, download and complete this application.