Give the Gift of Whiskey


We have a wall full of whiskey gifts, including some unique, rare and hard-to-find whiskeys. Look to the West wall, just through the Hobbit hole, for some tremendous whiskeys.

Booker’s Rye is really the crown jewel, recently named “World Whisky of the Year” for 2017 by Jim Murray’s Whisky Bible. It’s aged 13 years, and beat out 1,240 new whiskies for the honor, by being “simply a staggering example of magnificent rye showing exactly what genius in terms of whiskey actually means.”

Whistle Pig 15-year Rye is the distillery’s oldest whiskey, aged in repurposed bourbon barrels before being finished in new barrels built from oak grown on its own Vermont farm. 

Or, go for Whistle Pig 12-year Old World Rye. What they mean by “Old World” is that it’s finished in old Sauternes, Madeira, and Port barrels.

We love Michter’s, and had the pleasure of some of their premium offerings at Maxie’s Michter’s Whiskey Dinner in February. You can find them here, including Michter’s Barrel Strength Rye and Michter’s 10-year Bourbon. 

Maxie’s also hosted a High West Whiskey Dinner this year, and we have a few of their creative blends, including Midwinters’ Night Dram (rye finished in port and French oak barrels), Yippee Ki Yay (rye aged in vermouth and Syrah barrels), and Campfire (a rustic, smoky blend of bourbon, rye and scotch).

Plus, we have rarities from some big names, including Knob Creek 2001 14-year Bourbon, Wild Turkey Master’s Keeper 17-year Bourbon, Redemption 7-year Barrel Proof Rye, Jameson 18-year Irish Whiskey, and Laphroig Lore Scotch. 

Holiday Gift Packs from Story Hill BKC


12 Beers of Christmas

12 Beers of Christmas • 36.00

A dozen assorted, sought-after holiday brews. This is our most popular set, and a great gift for the craft beer lover in your life – or just a nice box to bring a long to a party! Beers may be subject to availability as we get closer to the big day, so pick up a pack soon!

Great Lakes Christmas Ale

Bell’s Christmas Ale

Shiner Holiday Bock

Southern Tier 2X XMAS

Abita Christmas Ale

Anchor Merry Christmas, Happy New Year

Deschutes Jubleale

Rogue Santa’s Private Reserve

Sierra Nevada Celebration

Point St. Benedict’s Ale

Victory Winter Cheers

Anderson Valley Winter Solstice

Bourbon, It’s Cold Outside • 65.00

Our Black Shoe 1792 Small Batch Bourbon, two whiskey tasting glasses, and a flask in a crafted wooden box.

Brandy Old Fashioned Kit • 50.00

Make ’em the way you like ’em with this bartending kit. A bottle of Korbel Brandy, bitters, sugar, cherries and a muddler to mash it all together.


4 Bottles • 85.00

Four bottles of wine in a vintage metal carrier. 2_wine

2 Bottles • 45.00

Two bottles of wine in a vintage metal carrier.

Coffee Gift Set with Black Shoe + Valentine mugs

Coffee Gift Set • 22.00

2 bags of Valentine coffee, 2 Black Shoe + Valentine travel mugs

Sparkling Gift Set • 35.00

A bottle of Bubz in a bucket! With a stick of rock candy, and a Champagne stopper, because sometimes we don’t finish the whole bottle.

Wine & Chocolate: That’s Just What I Wanted

Wine & Chocolate • 16.00

My only two weakness! Argh, how did you know! A bottle of red and a local Indulgence chocolate bar, wrapped up and ready to go.

Sip & Shop: National Bourbon Day at BKC

It’s #NationalBourbonDay, and we’ve got the goods to help you celebrate.


Whether you’re looking for The Oldest Fashioned on tap, to try something new or extremely nice, or to restock the home bar, Story Hill’s the spot to be. We’ll mix them into any drink you like, or enjoy them with some of our fancy ice cubes.

Check out our latest whiskey list for the most current selection of 25+ bourbons,* with almost all of them available to take home from our bottle shop (just make your purchases before 9 p.m.)! In the center of the shop, you’ll find a display of some really special stuff.

* (We’re are sold out of Pappy 12-year, unfortunately!)


Moscow Mules: Made in Wisco

Welcome the newest members of your family with a gift set to carry on a cocktail tradition: Moscow Mules. Packed up in wooden crate, it’s got the local ingredients and copper mugs to make a couple of your favorite spicy, refreshing drinks.

Included is a bottle of Black Dot Vodka, crafted in Madison, Wisc. at one of the Midwest’s oldest distilleries, from corn, yeast and water (i.e., gluten-free). It’s the “Swiss Army knife of spirits” – used here at Story Hill BKC, and at Blue’s Egg, to craft our version of the Moscow Mule (the Bluemound Buck, on tap) and all those Bloody Marys. It’s made right here in Wisconsin – and easily beats that dingy fowl Frenchie vodka.

Mix it with a few bottles of Belfast Ginger Beer, handcrafted in Janesville, Wisc. and pour it in a couple of copper mugs, and you can hang with the cool kids.

  • 1 bottle Black Dot Vodka
  • 3 bottles Belfast Ginger Beer
  • 2 copper mugs
  • Available in the Shop at Story Hill
  • 60 + tax

12 Beers of Christmas 2015

IMG_1258 One of our most popular gift sets, the 12 Beers of Christmas is a great present for the beer geek in your life, or to pick up and bring to a holiday party. The 12 Beers of Christmas – we filled a handcrafted wooden 12-pack with one dozen selections of craft beer’s ultimate holiday brews. Currently includes, subject to availability:

Southern Tier 2XMAS Double Spiced Ale

Shiner Holiday Cheer Dunkelweizen

Breckenridge Christmas Ale

Lakefront Holiday Spice Lager

Anchor Christmas Ale

Rogue Ales Santa’s Private Reserve

Bell’s Christmas Ale

Sierra Nevada Celebration Ale

Potosi Holiday Spice

Point St. Benedict’s Winter Ale

Great Lakes Christmas Ale

Abita Christmas Ale

Available at the Shop at Story Hill

36 + tax12pack

Rare, Exclusive Whiskey Gifts

‘Tis the season for whiskey – and we’ve got some good ones. These are the special editions and commemorative releases from some of the biggest brands in whiskey. For some selections we received a few bottles; more often, we could only get our hands on one bottle. If you see something you like, or something you’ve been looking for, be sure to stop by soon. Once these bottles leave our shelves, we don’t except to access more.
  • Wild Turkey Diamond Anniversary – 135
    • Created to honor Jimmy Russell, the master distiller who grew this brand over 60 years, by his son, master distiller Eddie Russell, Diamond Anniversary is a blend of 13- to 16-year bourbons.
  • Cutty Sark Prohibition Edition – 34
    • Small batch, single malt and top-quality grain whiskies are blended and aged in American oak casks to honor this Scotch’s Prohibition-era history.
  • Four Roses Limited Edition Small Batch – 110
    • Bottled at barrel strength and non-chill filtered, Four Roses master distillers occasionally release the very best barrels from their 10 bourbon recipes to great acclaim. SOLD OUT!
  • Russell’s Reserve Single Barrel Rye – 65
  • Willet Family Estate Bottled 8-year Rye – 89
  • 1792 Sweet Wheat – 49
  • Amador Double Barrel – 44

Start your holiday shopping at Story Hill BKC


We’re kicking off the holiday shopping season with our clever collections of treasures for the beverage enthusiast on your list. Make a selection from our award-winning wine list, pick out a craft beer for your next-get-together, or check out a few rare, ultra premium whiskies.

You can always pick up a Gift Card – good here at Story Hill BKC as well as at Blue’s Egg and Maxie’s. Your guest can savor our Upper Midwest-inspired cuisine for weekday lunch, weekend brunch and sharing plate dinner, or shop for their next favorite wine, beer or spirit (or buy it online here).

Pick up a pack of holiday cheer!

  • The Twelve Beers of Christmas – 36
  • Valentine Coffee Collection – 28
  • Moscow Mule Gift Set – 75
  • Schramsberg Sparkling Wine Collection – 65
  • Russell’s Whiskey Set – 95
  • Old Fashioned Kit
    • with Korbel Brandy – 50
    • with Four Roses Yellow Label – 60
  • Pinot & Cab Lovers Collection – 45
  • Beer Bomber & Growler Set – 60
  • Red, White & Rosé Collection – 27
  • Pinot Noir and Chocolate – 26

Father’s Day gifts at Story Hill

Whiskey: “It’s what I really wanted.”IMG_8893

Pick up presents for your pops in our Bottle Shop. We’ve packaged our very own Black Shoe Bourbon with a flask for a classy and classic gift.

We selected our own single barrel of bourbon from a blind tasting of Four Roses Bourbon. It’s served exclusively here, at Maxie’s and Blue’s Egg, and only sold here. With a stainless steel flask, he can bring six ounces of liquid goodness wherever he goes. Together for $50. We can help you find the wine, beer or spirit that will impress as a tasteful gift.

Pick up presents for your pops in our Bottle Shop. We’ve packaged our very own Black Shoe Bourbon with a flask for a classy and classic gift.

We selected our own single barrel of bourbon from a blind tasting of Four Roses Bourbon. It’s served exclusively at Maxie’sBlue’s Egg and Story Hill BKC, and only sold here. With a stainless steel flask, he can bring six ounces of liquid goodness wherever he goes. Together for $50.

We can help you find the wine, beer or spirit that will impress as a tasteful gift. Stop by and enjoy a half-glass of wine or a coffee while you browse for the new dad, granddad, uncle or stepdad on your list.


Bar Bites with Point Brewery, Monday, June 22


You could take dad to dinner – or you could treat him to a true experienceBar Bites is Story Hill BKC’s gastronomic showcase. Our goal is to delight you with decadence through thoughtful food pairings by co-owner Chef Joe Muench.

Bar Bites is a casual dining experience with limited seating in our bar area and direct access to our chefs and brewery representatives. On June 22, we welcome Point Brewery, including its Whole Hog Limited Edition series. You’ll definitely have the change to “pig out” on five unforgettable courses. Check out the menu here.

Bar Bites with Point Brewery, Mon., June 22 $65


Arrive at 6 p.m. for an hors d’oeuvres reception; 5 beer-paired courses begin at 6:30 p.m. Price includes reception, 5 courses, beer pairings and tax. Gratuity is not included.

Greeting cards by Artery Ink


A couple of longtime Maxie’s pros Mara and Gloria have created Artery Ink, a design company that’s all about encouraging you to eat healthier, take care of your body and love yourself a little bit more. Pick up an Artery Ink greeting card at Story Hill to include in your gift! $5 each.

Valentine’s gifts at Story Hill BKC

truffles giftbox   Grab the gift boxes, growlers and bottles you need to make an exceptional weekend. Complement the lushest red or a beautiful bubbly with Indulgence Chocolatiers‘ Aphrodisiac Truffle Collection. Sensual truffles of Ginger Passionfruit Caramel, Balsamic Fig, Rosewater Pistachio, Smoky Pomegranate, Bananas Foster, and Citrus Basil Honey are a sumptuous beginning – or end – to an evening.

Simple, but Significant — 36.00

fourmillesophoraIndulgence Chocolatiers’ Aphrodisiac Truffle Collection with:

Four Mile Creek, North Coast Red Wine, 2011 – an inky ruby red with a dark fruit and silky olive nose. Blended from syrah, zinfandel and grenache, it’s vibrant and straightforward. Mouth-warmingly plump, with jammy berry and bitter cherry flavors, and a peppery, smoky finish.


Sophora, Sparkling Rosé, New Zealand – Pretty in pink with delightful floral aromas and juicy red berries. Made from the big champagne grapes, chardonnay and pinot noir, for a beautiful blush color, luscious palate of pink grapefruit, and a creamy, decadent finish.

Elegant, extravagant — 48.00

peakjIndulgence Chocolatiers’ Aphrodisiac Truffle Collection with:

Queens Peak, Cabernet Sauvignon, Sonoma County, 2011 – An enchanting dark crimson red with aromas of blackberry cobbler and a bangin’ body. Rich dark fruit is followed by cocoa and ripe, velvety tannins.


 J Cuvée 20, NV Brut, Russian River Valley, Calif.– The special occasion sparkling, with crisp and lively green apple and cream notes. Bright tropical fruit and a hint of spice make it a great pair for opulent seafood like scallops or lobster.

Gift Set: Michter’s Whiskey

michters As if you needed more reasons to love whiskey. This three-bottle collection of small batch whiskeys offers a unique opportunity to taste and compare different styles of whiskey. Michter’s traces its legacy to 1753 and the very first whiskey company in America. Today, it continues as one of America’s most respected distilleries. Drawing from the distillery’s US✭1 expressions series, these are excellent examples of rye, bourbon and unblended American whiskey. Packaged in a handcrafted wooden tote, with tasting and distillation notes included.


Sun 9am-2pm


Tue-Fri 11am-9pm

Sat 9am-9pm

Shop always closed by 9pm


5100 W. Bluemound Rd. Milwaukee, Wisc.

PH 414.539.4424



DRINKS 2pm-6pm; MENU 3pm-5pm

$2 off tap cocktails

$2 off tap beer

$5 featured wine by the glass

To apply at Story Hill, download and complete this application.