Gift: 12 Beers of Christmas

12 Beers of Christmas • 36.00

A popular gift set every year, a great host gift for your next party or a stocking stuffer for the craft beer lover on your list. Beers may be subject to availability as we get closer to the big day, so pick up a pack soon!

  • Stone Xocoveza

  • Shiner Holiday Cheer

  • Bell’s Scotch Ale

  • Bell’s Winter White Ale

  • Samuel Adams Winter Lager

  • Uinta Season Pass

  • New Belgium Accumulation

  • Anderson Valley Winter Solstice

  • Lakefront Barrel-Aged Spiced Winter Lager

  • Deschutes Jubelale

  • Great Lakes Christmas Ale

  • Sierra Nevada Celebration 2017

  • Roll Out The Barrel For… Bar Bites Beer Bash

    We’re rolling out the barrel for our annual Bar Bites Beer Bash.

    Bar Bites Beer Bash is our annual walk-around tasting with food pairing stations on Monday, August 28. Tickets are available at Story Hill BKC for $60, which include beer tastings, food, tax and gratuity. 414-539-4424, Breweries include: Bell’s, Door County, Surly, New Glarus, Lakefront, Abita, Hinterland, O’so, Deschutes, Uinta, Black Husky, and Central Waters.

    Daddy Likes Whiskey: Father’s Day Gifts & Brunch

    We’re opening an hour early on Father’s Day, this Sunday, June 18, to serve brunch. We’ll open the doors at 8 a.m. to give everyone a chance to enjoy brunch on what hopefully will be a beautiful summer day.

    If you’re shopping for Father’s Day gifts, we have beer, wine, and whiskey for the fathers that appreciate “the good stuff.” Here are some of our premium whiskies available in the shop:

      • Michter’s 10-year Bourbon

      • Michter’s 10-year Rye

      • Michter’s Barrel Strength Rye

      • WhistlePig 15-year Rye

      • WhistlePig Old World Rye

      • Knob Creek 2001 Bourbon

      • Booker’s Limited Edition Rye

      • Jameson The Cooper’s Croze Irish Whiskey

      • Green Spot Irish Whiskey

      • Yellow Spot Irish Whiskey

      • Jefferson’s Groth Reserve Cask Bourbon

      • Jefferson’s Prichard Hill Cask Bourbon

      • Laphroig Lore Scotch

      • The Macallan Double Cask Scotch

      • High West Yippee Ki-Yay Rye

      • Wild Turkey Master’s Keep Boubon

      • Wild Turkey Generations Bourbon

      • Yamazaki 12-year Whiskey

      • Yamazaki 18-year Whiskey

        And of course, our 1792 private label Black Shoe Bourbon…always great! … especially for just $32.

        For when you want an amazing brunch, but you also want a growler filled with beer… Milwaukee Record names Story Hill BKC one of “12 great places to fill your growler in Milwaukee.”

        “They’re one of the best picks for tasty food and great growler options. Come for their amazing brunch, and leave with 64 ounces of beer to enjoy at home.”

    Bell’s Bar Bites Beer Dinner

    We’re excited to announce the next beer dinner in our Bar Bites series, and it’s a great match-up: Bell’s Brewery of Kalamazoo, Michigan. Since opening as a homebrew supply store in 1983, Bell’s has grown to produce beloved seasonal and specialty beer in the Upper Midwest such as Oberon, Two Hearted Ale, and Hopslam.

    On Monday, June 12, enjoy a 5-courses paired with Bell’s beer at Story Hill BKC starting at 6 p.m. $65 includes dinner, reception, and pairings; gratuity and tax not included. For reservations, call Story Hill BKC at 414-539-4424 or email

    Check out scenes from our most recent Bar Bites Beer Dinner.

    Spring in Europe

    Join us Monday, May 1 for a European-themed four-station tasting dinner. “Spring in Europe” celebrates the food, drink and culture of Europe. Enjoy beer and wine pairings from Bofferding and Domaines Vinsmoselle. Menu includes…

    • Cheese Display: Apricoit Onion Tart, Cherry Turnover

    • Chicon Au Gratin Toast: Endive, Carr Valley Gouda, Uphoff Ham

    • Duck Bratwurst w/ house sauerkraut, pickled mustard, pretzel roll

    • Capon Spaetzle: Black Pepper Spaetzle, Capon Caper Demi

    • Assorted Petit Fours: Apricoit Onion Tart, Cherry Turnover

    $60 for an individual; $100 for a couple. Every guest will receive a free gift bag, and be entered into a raffle for a grand prize of a $50 gift card. Includes gratuity; tax not included. Call Story Hill BKC at 414-539-4424 or email for reservations.

    Central Waters Bar Bites Beer Dinner

    Central Waters is among the best breweries for barrel-aging and environmental sustainablility – and they’re right here in Wisconsin. Join us for a Bar Bites beer dinner featuring the beer of Central Waters.

    RESERVATIONS ARE CURRENTLY FULL. We are accepting waitlist names. Call 414-539-4424 for reservations; reservations are required. Dinner is $65 and includes reception, 5 beer-paired courses; gratuity and tax not included. Reception begins at 6 p.m. with dinner to follow at 6:30 p.m.

    Holiday Gift Packs from Story Hill BKC


    12 Beers of Christmas

    12 Beers of Christmas • 36.00

    A dozen assorted, sought-after holiday brews. This is our most popular set, and a great gift for the craft beer lover in your life – or just a nice box to bring a long to a party! Beers may be subject to availability as we get closer to the big day, so pick up a pack soon!

    Great Lakes Christmas Ale

    Bell’s Christmas Ale

    Shiner Holiday Bock

    Southern Tier 2X XMAS

    Abita Christmas Ale

    Anchor Merry Christmas, Happy New Year

    Deschutes Jubleale

    Rogue Santa’s Private Reserve

    Sierra Nevada Celebration

    Point St. Benedict’s Ale

    Victory Winter Cheers

    Anderson Valley Winter Solstice

    Bourbon, It’s Cold Outside • 65.00

    Our Black Shoe 1792 Small Batch Bourbon, two whiskey tasting glasses, and a flask in a crafted wooden box.

    Brandy Old Fashioned Kit • 50.00

    Make ’em the way you like ’em with this bartending kit. A bottle of Korbel Brandy, bitters, sugar, cherries and a muddler to mash it all together.


    4 Bottles • 85.00

    Four bottles of wine in a vintage metal carrier. 2_wine

    2 Bottles • 45.00

    Two bottles of wine in a vintage metal carrier.

    Coffee Gift Set with Black Shoe + Valentine mugs

    Coffee Gift Set • 22.00

    2 bags of Valentine coffee, 2 Black Shoe + Valentine travel mugs

    Sparkling Gift Set • 35.00

    A bottle of Bubz in a bucket! With a stick of rock candy, and a Champagne stopper, because sometimes we don’t finish the whole bottle.

    Wine & Chocolate: That’s Just What I Wanted

    Wine & Chocolate • 16.00

    My only two weakness! Argh, how did you know! A bottle of red and a local Indulgence chocolate bar, wrapped up and ready to go.

    Bar Bites featuring Surly, Dec. 5

    Join us for Bar Bites, a 5-course beer dinner featuring Surly Brewing, on Monday, Dec. 5. With its must-visit destination brewery in the Twin Cities, Surly has become Wisconsin’s favorite Minnesotan import. Surly believes in making great beer, having fun, and giving a damn about your community, and we can get down with that philosophy. Call 414-539-4424 for reservations; reservations are required. Dinner is $65 and includes reception, 5 beer-paired courses; gratuity and tax not included. Reception begins at 6 p.m. with dinner to follow at 6:30 p.m.

    Beers featured include: Cynic – Belgian Style Saison 6.7% Abrasive Ale – 2x IPA 9.0% Pentagram – Brett Dark Beer aged in Wine barrels 6.6% Damien – Dry Hopped Black Ale 8.0% Darkness 2015 – Russian Imperial Stout 10.4%

    Check out the awesomeness that ensued last year, when we hosted a Surly Bar Bites.  Here’s a look at the menu:

    Reception & Tasting w/ Hell

    1. Chicon Au Gratin

    Endive, LaBelle, Uphoff Ham

    with Cynic

    2. Veal Sweetbread-Stuffed Quail

    Charcoal Roasted, Leek and Wild Rice Ragout, Smoked Beets, Abrasive Gravy

    with Abrasive Ale

    3. Seared Pork Cheek

    Potato Waffle, Apple Frisée Salad, Caramel Cracklings

    with Pentagram

    4. Beef “Stroganoff”

    Über Rich Mushrooms, Black Garlic Noodles, Ember Greens, Heavenly Crème Fraîche

    with Damien

    5. Caramel Nut Tart

    with Darkness 2015


    Lakefront’s Brandy Barrel-Aged Cherry Lager Tapping, Aug. 16


    We’re tapping Lakefront Brewery’s anticipated Brandy Barrel-Aged Cherry Lager starting at 5 p.m. on Tuesday, Aug. 16. If you like Old Fashioneds, Lagers, and/or Lakefront beer, you’ll really like this cherry delight!

    $7/small tulip. We’ll also have Lakefront’s SMaSH Ale on tap and, as always, Riverwest Stein. Let your friends you wanna drink some beer on our Facebook Event.

    Bar Bites Beer Bash


    We’re hosting eight regional craft breweries at a lively beer-centric tasting event on August 29 at 6 p.m. More of a party than a sit-down dinner, we’ll serve up plenty of our Upper Midwest-inspired cuisine from food pairing stations. Breweries joining us at the Beer Bash include Lakefront, O’so, Surly, Potosi, New Glarus, Point, Hinterland, and Door County.

    $50; includes tasting and food pairings; tax and gratuity not included. Call us at 414-539-4424 to reserve your spot! Check out some scenes from previous Bar Bites below…



    Sun 9am-2pm

    Mon CLOSED

    Tue-Fri 11am-9pm

    Sat 9am-9pm

    Shop always closed by 9pm

    Bar & Shop Only 2-3pm Menus


    5100 W. Bluemound Rd. Milwaukee, Wisc.

    PH 414.539.4424



    DRINKS 2pm-6pm; MENU 3pm-5pm

    $2 off tap cocktails

    $2 off tap beer

    $5 featured wine by the glass

    To apply at Story Hill, download and complete this application.